New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew SC, MLS 2024 REGULAR SEASON

Refresh

MLS · 2024

New York Red Bulls

2 – 3

Full Time

Columbus Crew SC

Sat 19 Oct 2024 · 22:00 UTC Red Bull Arena HT 45' · FT 45'

Y 35' Derrick Jones

Y 45' Max Arfsten

Y 47' Malte Amundsen

Serge Ngoma 89' Y

Overview

Match Preview

New York Red Bulls vs Columbus Crew SC — MLS at Red Bull Arena.

New York Red Bulls 15 games · 22 pts (2026/26)
Columbus Crew SC 15 games · 16 pts (2026/26)

Standings

#	Team	P	Pts
1	Nashville SC	14	33
2	Internacional CF Miami	15	31
3	Chicago Fire FC	14	26
4	New England Revolution	14	25
5	New York Red Bulls	15	22
6	Charlotte FC	15	21
7	FC Cincinnati	15	20
8	New York City FC	15	19
9	D.C. United SC	15	18
10	Columbus Crew SC	15	16
11	Toronto FC	14	14
12	Montreal Impact FC	14	14
13	Orlando City SC	15	14
14	Atlanta United FC	14	11
15	Philadelphia Union	15	7
16	Vancouver Whitecaps FC	14	32
17	San Jose Earthquakes	15	32
18	Real Salt Lake	14	26
19	FC Dallas	15	25
20	Los Angeles FC	15	24
21	Seattle Sounders FC	13	24
22	Houston Dynamo	14	22
23	Minnesota United FC	15	22
24	Los Angeles Galaxy	15	20
25	San Diego FC	15	17
26	Colorado Rapids SC	15	16
27	St. Louis City	14	16
28	Portland Timbers	14	14
29	Austin FC	15	14
30	Sporting Kansas City	14	11

Head-to-Head

New York Red Bulls 20 games · Avg 2.8 goals Columbus Crew SC

Last 5 meetings

2024-10-19 New York Red Bulls 2–3 Columbus Crew SC 2024-03-16 Columbus Crew SC 3–0 New York Red Bulls 2023-07-01 Columbus Crew SC 2–1 New York Red Bulls 2023-03-18 New York Red Bulls 2–1 Columbus Crew SC 2022-10-01 Columbus Crew SC 2–1 New York Red Bulls

Recent Form

New York Red Bulls

Date	Opponent	H/A	Score	Result
19 Oct	Columbus Crew SC	H	2–3	L
05 Oct	Atlanta United FC	A	1–2	L
02 Oct	Toronto FC	A	4–1	W
28 Sep	New York City FC	H	1–5	L
21 Sep	Atlanta United FC	H	2–2	D
15 Sep	Chicago Fire FC	A	1–2	L

Columbus Crew SC

Date	Opponent	H/A	Score	Result
19 Oct	New York Red Bulls	A	3–2	W
12 Oct	New England Revolution	H	4–0	W
05 Oct	Philadelphia Union	H	3–2	W
02 Oct	Internacional CF Miami	H	2–3	L
28 Sep	D.C. United SC	A	2–2	D
21 Sep	Orlando City SC	H	4–3	W

Season Stats

New York Red Bulls		Columbus Crew SC
#5	Position	#10
22	Points	16
15	Played	15
6 / 4 / 5	W / D / L	4 / 4 / 7
25	Scored	21
32	Conceded	23
-7	GD	-2
1.47	PPG	1.07
40%	Win %	27%

Key Stats

65% Both Teams to Score
H2H (20 games)

60% Over 2.5 Goals
H2H history

20% Clean Sheets
New York Red Bulls this season

27% Clean Sheets
Columbus Crew SC this season

New York Red Bulls are 5th (22 pts). Columbus Crew SC are 10th (16 pts).

Goal Timing (This Season)

New York Red Bulls

0-15

5/1

16-30

1/1

31-45

3/5

46-60

3/5

61-75

1/2

76+

3/2

■ Scored ■ Conceded

Columbus Crew SC

0-15

2/3

16-30

2/1

31-45

2/1

46-60

3/2

61-75

1/2

76+

1/2

■ Scored ■ Conceded

Events

Match Events

0' The game is set. New York Red Bulls kicks off things out of here…
2' Assisted by Cucho Hernandez with the perfectly-timed delivery and Aziel Jackson makes no mistake. 0-1!
7' While there is no rush on the pitch, let’s have a look at some stats. John Tolkin made 283 appearances and scored 8 goals. He is very likely to score a goal today.
12' Both teams are passing the ball around with high level of urgency. New York Red Bulls needs to do something about it to get closer to the goal.
14' Against the run of play, Yevgen Cheberko has scored! This game has turned on its head.
19' USA international Christian Ramirez has been a key figure this campaign — 2 goals and 1 assists in the Array this season.
24' It is a cagey affair so far. New York Red Bulls in their trying to find a way past Columbus Crew SC's compact .
29' Andres Reyes, a Colombia , has 4 bookings this season and will need to keep his discipline tonight.
34' New York Red Bulls looks like a favorite considering 1 games won in last 1 matches with its main striker Julian Hall scoring 1 goals.
35' Derrick Jones has been a danger all night but risks an early exit having now seen a card on 35.
40' The referee is likely to let players tackle, as he already missed some meaty challenges during opening seconds. He is still to establish what should not be done by the players and what is acceptable on the pitch. It’s going to be a tough game for Lewis Morgan suffering a number of foals already.
45' The referee reaches into his pocket. Out comes the card for Max Arfsten.
46' The New York Red Bulls bench stirs into life. Peter Stroud is withdrawn and Cameron Harper gets his opportunity.
47' The referee calls foul for Malte Amundsen. He receives a card.
52' It looks like no one’s ball. Columbus Crew SC is used to counterattacking playing. None of the sides are ready to take the lead.
57' will be watching from the dugout nervously. His New York Red Bulls side need to improve if they are to claim all three points.
61' A change in the Columbus Crew SC ranks — Aziel Jackson exits the field as Christian Ramirez enters on 61.
62' It is a substitution in Columbus Crew SC team. Cucho Hernandez is replaced by Diego Rossi on 62 minute.
67' The crowd applauds Felipe Carballo as he leaves the pitch. Serge Ngoma steps in for New York Red Bulls.
72' New York Red Bulls are enjoying more possession but struggling to find a way through a disciplined Columbus Crew SC backline.
73' Sean Zawadzki gets the nod from Columbus Crew SC. He replaces Alexandru Matan and will look to change the dynamic.
78' Emil Forsberg makes no mistake. The score reads 1-2 and New York Red Bulls are in front.
80' The crowd applauds Max Arfsten as he leaves the pitch. DeJuan Jones steps in for Columbus Crew SC.
85' Ronald Donkor is a natural and has been asked to do a very specific job for New York Red Bulls tonight.
87' What a moment for Emil Forsberg! That strike on 87 puts his side firmly in control.
88' Fresh legs for New York Red Bulls! Aidan O'Connor comes on to replace Andres Reyes.
89' The referee has no hesitation. Serge Ngoma is booked for New York Red Bulls — card on 89.
The points are shared — New York Red Bulls 2-3 Columbus Crew SC. Honours even.

Lineups

New York Red Bulls Lineups

Starting XI

10
Emil Forsberg
9
Lewis Morgan
15
Sean Nealis
13
Dante Vanzeir ↓ Elias Manoel 67'
47
John Tolkin
4
Andres Reyes ↓ Aidan O'Connor 88'
31
Carlos Coronel
75
Daniel Edelman ↓ Wikelmann Carmona 80'
5
Peter Stroud ↓ Cameron Harper 46'
20
Felipe Carballo ↓ Serge Ngoma 67'
48
Ronald Donkor

Bench

18
Ryan Meara
17
Cameron Harper ↑ 46'
11
Elias Manoel ↑ 67'
22
Serge Ngoma ↑ 67'
19
Wikelmann Carmona ↑ 80'
16
Julian Hall
2
Dennis Gjengaar
23
Aidan O'Connor ↑ 88'
37
Mohammed Sofo

Coach Sandro Schwarz

Columbus Crew SC Lineups

Starting XI

9
Cucho Hernandez ↓ Diego Rossi 62'
7
Dylan Chambost
18
Malte Amundsen
20
Alexandru Matan ↓ Sean Zawadzki 73'
5
Derrick Jones ↓ Jacen Russell-Rowe 46'
2
Marcelo Herrera
4
Rudy Camacho
13
Aziel Jackson ↓ Christian Ramirez 61'
27
Max Arfsten ↓ DeJuan Jones 80'
21
Yevgen Cheberko
1
Nicholas Hagen

Bench

14
Yaw Yeboah
17
Christian Ramirez ↑ 61'
10
Diego Rossi ↑ 62'
6
Darlington Nagbe
12
DeJuan Jones ↑ 80'
28
Patrick Schulte
25
Sean Zawadzki ↑ 73'
19
Jacen Russell-Rowe ↑ 46'

Coach Wilfried Nancy

H2H

H2H Top Scorers

Player	Goals
Daniel Royer	4
Gyasi Zardes	4
Darlington Nagbe	3
Pedro Santos	3
Emil Forsberg	2
Jonathan Mensah	2
Miguel Berry	2
Cucho Hernandez	2

Head to Head

New York Red Bulls Form

2024-10-19 New York Red Bulls 2–3 Columbus Crew SC L 2024-10-05 Atlanta United FC 2–1 New York Red Bulls L 2024-10-02 Toronto FC 1–4 New York Red Bulls W 2024-09-28 New York Red Bulls 1–5 New York City FC L 2024-09-21 New York Red Bulls 2–2 Atlanta United FC D 2024-09-15 Chicago Fire FC 2–1 New York Red Bulls L

Columbus Crew SC Form

2024-10-19 New York Red Bulls 2–3 Columbus Crew SC W 2024-10-12 Columbus Crew SC 4–0 New England Revolution W 2024-10-05 Columbus Crew SC 3–2 Philadelphia Union W 2024-10-02 Columbus Crew SC 2–3 Internacional CF Miami L 2024-09-28 D.C. United SC 2–2 Columbus Crew SC D 2024-09-21 Columbus Crew SC 4–3 Orlando City SC W

Predictions

Prediction accuracy

4 / 4

1.72 New York Red Bulls xG

Expected Goals

Dixon-Coles · Bivariate Poisson · Neg. Binomial · Elo

2.26 Columbus Crew SC xG

I would bet for: Over 2.5 goals 75% + Both teams to score 73%

Match Result

✓ Correct

New York Red Bulls29% Draw23% Columbus Crew SC48%

Actual: Columbus Crew SC win

Both Teams to Score

✓ Correct

Yes73% 0% No27%

Avg goals/match: 3.98

Actual: Yes — both scored

Over / Under Goals

✓ O/U 2.5

Line	Over	Under
± 0.5	97%	3%
± 1.5	90%	10%
± 2.5	75%	25%
± 3.5	55%	45%
± 4.5	37%	63%

Double Chance

New York Red Bulls or Draw

52%

Draw or Columbus Crew SC

71%

New York Red Bulls or Columbus Crew SC

77%

Half-Time Result

✓ Correct

New York Red Bulls25% Draw38% Columbus Crew SC37%

Actual: Columbus Crew SC win at HT

Correct Score

✓ In top 12

1 – 1

1 – 2

2 – 2

6.7%

2 – 1

6.1%

1 – 3

5.9%

2 – 3

Actual

0 – 2

4.9%

3 – 2

3.9%

0 – 1

3.8%

0 – 3

3.6%

3 – 1

3.5%

1 – 4

3.4%

Asian Handicap — New York Red Bulls

Handicap	New York Red Bulls covers	Push	Columbus Crew SC covers
-2.5	6%	—	94%
-2	6%	9%	85%
-1.5	15%	—	85%
-1	15%	14%	71%
-0.5	29%	—	71%
+0.5	51%	—	49%
+1	51%	19%	30%
+1.5	70%	—	30%
+2	70%	15%	15%
+2.5	85%	—	15%

Clean Sheet

New York Red Bulls keeps clean sheet

11% ✓

Columbus Crew SC keeps clean sheet

19% ✓

Predictions are statistical estimates based on season form, H2H history, and a Poisson model. Not financial advice.